Phone answered 24-hours
Free (866) 246-3280
Post Office Box 719
Royal Oak, MI 48068-0719
Phone: (248) 647-6890
Fax: (248) 647-4233
Bar Unplugs Net based Defense Firm
July 30, 2007
From the San Francisco California Recorder Monday July 9, 2007
Working for Robert Nudelman must have been a really bad experience because some of the fellow lawyers in his Woodland Hills, CA firm decided to take him down.
State Bar officials announced July 9, 2007 that they shut down Nudelmans Criminal Defense Associates Inc. last week because the firm had become incapable of properly representing its 150 clients who face criminal charges.
Nudelman resigned from practicing law immediately, officials said in a press statement, after the State Bar seized about 700 files, froze the firms bank accounts and placed it under the jurisdiction of the Los Angeles County Superior Court.
California State Bar Deputy Trial Counsel Kimberly Anderson said July 9,
2007 that some of
the lawyers employed by Nudelman are largely responsible for stopping Nudelman before things got worse.
They were concerned, she said. Some of them are pretty competent criminal defense attorneys.
Many of these attorneys, Anderson added, have been concerned about their clients and have come forward to help us.
Nudelman was managing partner and sole shareholder of Criminal Defense Associates, which was created in 2003 and marketed itself mostly on the Internet as a nationwide law firm specializing in sexual and drug offenses.
The firm employed about 10 criminal defense lawyers and accepted cases from all over the country.
State Bar Chief Trial Counsel Scott Drexel said the firms business model was fraught with problems. He said the firm appeared to violate multiple provisions of the Bars professional conduct rules, including engaging in the unauthorized practice of law, failing to refund unearned fees and not maintaining client funds in a trust account.
In some cases, Drexel noted, the firms lawyers were giving legal advice to clients in states in which they didnt have the right to practice law.
Were finding that more and more in the day of Internet advertising and the like, he said.
In fact, Nudelman blamed the Internet on his problems. In a declaration filed with the State Bars action in Los Angeles County Superior Court, Nudelman claimed his firm became insolvent because the cost of Internet advertising began exceeding the amount the firm was receiving in fees.
Nonetheless, the State Bar noted, Nudelman kept accepting fees of about $50,000 per case while going bankrupt.
The problems created by Criminal Defense Associates Inc., Drexel said in a prepared statement, graphically demonstrate the inherent danger to potential clients and the public in the operation of a nationwide law firm based largely upon Internet advertising and without adequate administrative controls or supervision.
In a telephone interview on Monday, Drexel said the State Bar shut down about 30 firms last year.
A number of them, it may be because the attorney has died or become incapacitated or just left the practice. Or sometimes they abandoned the practice, he said. But there have been a dozen cases or so in the last year where we felt the attorney was incapable of practicing competently and was endangering the clients money.
Neither Drexel nor Anderson would say whether any of the firms other attorneys are being investigated.
Telephone calls to Criminal Defense Associates Inc. were redirected Monday to the State Bar, where a recorded voice advised clients that the firms files are being inventoried and that letters will be mailed soon telling how to retrieve them. It also advises clients to contact the Los Angeles County Bar Associations lawyer referral service.
Andersonsaid clients might need to secure new counsel and that Nudelman is required to return unearned fees. But the problem is he says he doesnt have them, she said. [Clients] may have a civil action against him.
Two of the firms lawyers Kristine Burk of Sebastopoland Evan Zelig of Woodland Hills asked the State Bar to place their contact information on the Bars recorded message so clients could reach them.